• Happy First Use of Insulin to Treat Diabetes (1922)! ⚕️💉

Important Question Here

Joined
Nov 14, 2018
Messages
1,609
Reaction score
785
Location
Heart of the Shawnee Nation
Ok, so I've got a collection of griddles that would sink the Queen E II. Alas, however, the all important cast iron griddle to fit a Coleman Stove (with wind deflectors in place) has eluded me. Does anyone know a source for a Coleman fitting cast iron griddle or have one that you wish to depart with? A grease trap would be nice but not requisite. Thanks.
 
I have just a standard two-burner Coleman stove. I also have cast iron griddles that seem to fit nicely on top. Should I place the griddle on the metal pan/pot supports above the burners, or should I remove these supports? Would the latter cause too much heat, or restrict air flow?
 
I have just a standard two-burner Coleman stove. I also have cast iron griddles that seem to fit nicely on top. Should I place the griddle on the metal pan/pot supports above the burners, or should I remove these supports? Would the latter cause too much heat, or restrict air flow?

PP, if I am reading you correctly we have always used the metal grid support above the Coleman burners to hold the griddle, pots, pans or etc. I do not know, but sitting the pan or griddle directly on the flame burner bowl might snuff out the flame, or at least make it impossible to gauge the flame height/heat. Once the cast iron got hot it didn’t take much flame to keep it at the desired grilling temperature.

For group trip short order breakfasts the wide Lodge griddle fit across both burners. Since the left side auxiliary burner is always weaker than the primary right we had two temperature griddle sides and could move things back and forth as needed.

Our 2-burned griddle is like this

https://shop.lodgemfg.com/griddles-and-grill-pans/pro-grid-iron-reversible-grill-griddle.asp

But it has a grease trap lip indentation at the front. I think it is a Lodge, but I’d have to go check.

Actually I’d have to go find it and check. That thing was wonderful when we did group trips with a 2 burner Coleman and short-order chef friends, willing to man the morning griddle and make (and keep making) eggs, sausage, pancakes and homefries. Not to mention corned beef hash, fried green tomatoes. . . . .soft shell crabs. . . sometimes that was a two-person or even two-stove operation, but dang it was fun to watch in action. And delicious.

My solo oatmeal, breakfast bar and instant coffee is sounding pretty weak.
 
You did understand me correctly, Mike. Thanks! I will give it a try in the next day our so. This seems a lot better than trying to fry bacon in a small pan, or using a portable BBQ for burgers, which has never worked all that great. With this approach we can leave the skillet and BBQ at home. We just need to find an appropriate container for the griddle.
 
For what it's worth I have my parents 3 burner Coleman stove that was bought before I was born. It still works fine and as far as putting a griddle on it we had one with a well for bacon grease to drain into. I don't know what the hell the griddle is called as it is tucked deep into a place in the barn long forgotten where in the hell did I put it kind of thing. I know I will find it one day when I'm not looking for it because the more I look for it the more it will move into a more elusive spot!

I'm sure this has never happened to any of you folks. All I recall is it fit perfectly over two of the burners leaving the third open for frying eggs on a small pan. dang it, now I'm going to have to go on a search for that elusive piece of metal. I don't whether to curse you BF for starting this thread or to thank you.

dougd
 
I've got a square lodge griddle, with handles that preclude it from fitting precisely unless I fold the wind screen in. I've got another griddle that extends past the ends of the stove. I've got a steel one with folding handles that is also too big. The best fitting griddle I have is an aluminum/teflon job which I abhor. I'm going to try MIke's reference and see what happens. I ran over my vintage Coleman stove with a popup trailer 12 years ago. I don't think the replacement is the same dimensions, but I could be wrong. Sure isn't built like the old one.
 
Another satisfied owner/user of the Lodge cast iron griddle in combination with a standard two-burner stove. Works well. Only downside is the thing weighs a bloody ton!
 
B_F I just found a reference to a Coleman nonstick griddle Pat. No. 330204 that might work for you.

Also a Vintage Coleman Camp Stove Griddle Aluminum Casting Grill on a google search
 
I'm sure this has never happened to any of you folks. All I recall is it fit perfectly over two of the burners leaving the third open for frying eggs on a small pan. dang it, now I'm going to have to go on a search for that elusive piece of metal. I don't whether to curse you BF for starting this thread or to thank you.

Doug, I spent a half hour yesterday on a step stool searching the top shelf in the gear room for our griddle. We haven’t used in since the days of big group trips and I think it is buried somewhere. Looked under piles of old gear, in the miscellaneous camp gear box and the miscellaneous cookwear box on the bottom shelf, even in the kitchen cabinets. I’m sure we still have it, but I dunno where, and now I can’t seem to stop searching.

Ours was not the Lodge griddle I linked to earlier in this thread, it was short enough to fit between the wind wings on a standard 2-burner Coleman, and it had a recessed grease trap lip on the flat griddle side.

This smaller Lodge griddle would fit better (16 ¾” long x 9 ½” deep). I think ours was a little narrower, it fit between the 16ish inch back of the Coleman wind wings perfectly.

https://shop.lodgemfg.com/griddles-and-grill-pans/double-play-reversible-grill-griddle.asp

We just need to find an appropriate container for the griddle.

Those I did find, flat vinyl dry bags with a roll over top that affixed with three clasps. Cheapies I found in an Army surplus/camping store. I turned up a couple of those on the shelves, including one that still contained an old campfire grill top.
 
My stove must not be standard. A 20" griddle is too long for my 2 burner 425. I have the Lodge 20x10 and love it, but I can't use my wind screens. Alas, it may be a fools errand to keep searching. I may just suffer along with my bakers dozen of poor fitting griddles. I don't want to need to reinforce my foundation. I also have a non-stick job with a grease well, but nothing works like cast iron.
 
Last edited:
Back
Top