I have a different view of where the fault lies for the low quality of much, if not most, of the products we buy. We are at fault both individually and collectively for much of the problem. When we accept shoddy products as the cost of our collective drive (obsession?) to pay the lowest price we force manufacturers to follow us into the basement. In a world where we demand a sub $20 12" skillet by Lodge at Target or Walmart we only need to look in the mirror to see the ultimate culprit when we are dissatisfied with the quality.
We're the same folks who far too often drove past the smaller grocer, local shoe shop, hardware store etc who used to pay what the trendy now call a "living wage" to shop at Walmart and Lowes where management gets bonuses for preventing workers from achieving full time status and earning benefits and then we bemoan the loss of small business and the empty storefronts in almost any town center.
So let's put the blame where it ultimately rests: On the millions of consumers who value low prices and convenience over marketplace diversity, personal service and high quality.
Now please excuse me while I get down off my soapbox and store my pulpit away.......
Like others here I have an assortment of older and modern cast iron cookware. I have Dutch "camp" ovens from 8-14", regular Dutch ovens, 5-6 skillets and griddles up to 26" long. The surface smoothness, handle size, placement and shape, fit of lids if any etc vary but all cook well when properly cared for and seasoned. With just two of us most of the time our workhorse cast iron skillets are both around 10" across the cooking surface.
The Lodge "Chef Series" skillets seem to have a good reputation and trend quite a bit lighter than the "Classic" skillets for not much more money. Their shape is more of a French skillet shape than the steep straight sides of the Classic skillets. I haven't used or even held one though....
Victoria skillets have a good reputation and come factory seasoned at high temperature with flaxseed oil, my personal seasoning of choice. Finding a retailer can be tough so this may be a case of being forced to deal with the evil empire of Amazon.. I just took a shot and ordered a 12" Victoria skillet. I'll report back after it has had a little use.
By the way, I've found that with heavy and hard to damage goods you can sometimes get really good deals on Amazon by checking "other sellers" link. The Amazon Warehouse folks often have new stuff in damaged boxes at great prices. I just paid $21 for the Victoria 12" skillet in new undamaged condition due to a damaged box....
Best Regards to all,
Lance