I just wondered over from that other paddling forum, figured I'd add my comment to this thread as my first post here........
Opinions on Mountain House freeze dried meals? Looking at possibly buying the 20 oz. can and separating into vacuum sealed bags for multiple trips just for convenience. Are these worth buying? I could always experiment and dehydrate my own but I'm not a chef
I like to cook at home and I like to cook when paddling if I have companions along and it's a relatively easy trip of modest duration (ie: <7 days) where weight, bulk and time are not issues.
I've always brought along a few meal in a bag (MIAB) for "emergency" use but in the last 15 years or so I've converted to mostly MIAB for my longer trips and especially for the long solo trips.
I've found the quality and variety available these days has improved dramatically in recent years. The salt content of most has come down a lot since the 80's & 90's and the flavour factor has gone up a lot. Unfortunately the cost per serving has also risen quite a bit especially for those north of the 49th. On most trips these days I plan on using MIAB for 6 days out of 7 with the 7th day covered by my own rice or pasta based meals using an assortment of off the shelf ingredients.
I started out with mostly Backpackers Pantry, with a few Mountain House but in the last couple of years I've transitioned to mostly Alpine Aire with a few MH + BP. There is more variety with AA and they are slightly smaller (similar to MH Pro-Paks) which suits my needs and means I rarely fail to consume a full bag.
I really just like the simplicity, get to camp, set-up, relax in my bug/rain shelter, boil some water, eat, lick spoon, seal bag (wash it out in the morning)
My tips for happy eating......
1 - Buy a variety until you determine which ones to never buy again!
2 - Calorie content varies, keep that in mind
3 - Presume you will need additional items (apps/dessert) to supplement, even the high cal bags are only 650-700 cals, not enough for the active paddler
4 - Purchase a "long spoon", titanium preferably (this one is nice
https://www.mec.ca/en/product/5024-534/Titanium-Long-Spoon)
5 - Measure water carefully, I find slightly less than instructed works well, also note that not all "cups" are created equal, better to use "ml"
6 - Rehydrate time, that 10 - 12 minutes they claim is garbage, I rarely soak less than 20 minutes and some meals benefit from a few more than that
7 - Bring some hot sauce to overcome the blandness factor
8 - Don't fully tear off the top of the bag, it's just one more small piece of trash to keep track of
9 - Rinse the empty bags and pack them out, they do not burn well. they also make for good "trash" bags when out on the river and you have a new one to use almost every day
Here are the remnants of my 46 day summer trip, 36 MIAB, 32 "different" varieties (how different can rice & chicken or pasta & sauce be?), mostly AA with a few MH & BP. The other days were a combo of a few fresh items, a few things from the grocery shelf and a few days of snacking only.