• Happy National Banana Bread Day! 🍌🍞

National Boy Scouts Day

Joined
Oct 29, 2019
Messages
680
Reaction score
1,248
Location
southeast PA
Were it not for Boy Scouting, I would likely not be here enjoying this forum today! Scouting and a particularly charismatic Scoutmaster defined much of who and what I am to this day 62 years after becoming a Scout. The Scout motto, oath, and laws remain defining guideposts for me. Canoeing is just a small part of the skill and outdoor pursuits I gained from Scouting. Any others have their canoeing experience starting in Boy Scouts? Thanks Glenn for posting the header today.


From the local newspaper in 1986!
IMG_1532.jpeg
 
Last edited:
We had an excellent scout troop. Our Scoutmaster was a local WW2 hero to us young boys, that not only taught us outdoor skills but what it meant to be a family man, good citizen and member of society.
 
We started canoeing with the Scouts at age 10 and learned to backpack. We had an outdoor trip once a month year around.
Our troop folded after our Scoutmaster got sick. We joined the Christian Service Bridgade, which was similar but we had to learn scripture. I took canoeing at church camp as a class. The instructor was a hard arse but he taught us to paddle solo in the wind. I was about 12.
 
Scouting started me canoeing, bouncing from bank to bank in the C&O Canal. After a while I learned to paddle straight.
I learned leadership, citizenship, conservation ethics, and love of the outdoors. I learned practical skills, such as pitching a tent, building a fire, using a map and compass, and raiding another troop's campsite.....

I would not be the same person without Scouting.
 
I was in Scouts from 11 thru college graduation, worked at the council's summer camps and was very active in the Order of the Arrow. I credit much of what I've become to scouting and, to this day, I remain friends with my old scoutmaster. Granted, he took the smokes from our c-rations but I've come to really appreciate what he did for a bunch of snot-nosed kids.

He served in the Army reserve so one weekend a month was spoken for and he took the scout troop out one weekend a month year-round. In all Chris lived for almost 15 years having only 4 days a month to do as he pleased.

I've recently learned that he'd always wanted to build a strip canoe so he may be very involved in my next build.
 
I got my start canoeing while in the scouts. I enjoyed summer camp so much that I starting working on the camp staff in 1963, after 4 summers as a camper. That first summer on staff I was paid $5/week as I recall.

I really enjoyed scouts from Cub Scouts to the local Sea Scout ship. Unfortunately, I picked a troop which was active for the first couple of years and then folded with me being the last member. The scout master and his assistant took me on a weekend camping trip and I earned Cooking and Camping merit badges (because I did most of the work) and after that trip the troop was kaput. Next I joined the local Sea Scout ship and we did some fun activities on Lake Michigan going out of the local USCG station. When I came back from summer camp in 1964, the ship had dissolved with me again being the final member. I guess I brought bad juju to the scout groups I affiliated with. After that I lost interest in the scouts and gave up working towards Eagle Scout - and I only needed about 5 or 6 merit badges to gain Eagle. I have regretted not earning the Eagle.
 
I spent a very few short years in scouts as a kid, until my rural small town troop disbanded when the scoutmaster quit and no one else was willing to step up to the task.

Many years later when my son entered Cubs, my wife volunteered as den mother. When my son advanced to Boy Scouts I became an assistant scoutmaster and my wife was troop committee chair for a few years.

Some time after that, a friend at work who was deeply involved in BSA wilderness training and winter activities for scouts asked me to assist with the Council high adventure training program. Soon after he asked me to attend the Adirondack trek leader wilderness guide training program he chaired at BSA National Camping School in the Adirondacks. From that experience, the next year I was asked to join the training staff for that program. We went on to actually write the high adventure wilderness training procedure document that became the written BSA high adventure training standard, as modified for the characteristics in each region of the country.

For the next 30 years I was one of the permanent annual staff instructors, specializing in teaching canoeing, land navigation, and camp food. Our students, typically of college age, but with a few older guys thrown in. Once successfully certified during the 8 days of combination classroom and Adirondack field exercise training, they could be hired to work at one of the regions resident summer camps, leading scouts and their adult leaders on week-long canoe and/or backpacking trips into the Adirondack wilderness.

From their training experience, many essliy go on to pass the exam to become NYS licensed wilderness guides. in fact, a long time past president of the NYS Guides Association was also a long time active adult sccouter, and the state asked him to write the state licensed guide's written exam. At least 90% of the exam general outdoor skills questions are thus taken directly from the official BSA Field Guide book (different from the BSA handbook).

We instructors had a fairly strict criteria for students to graduate from the program, and not everyone always passed. If not, then no summer job with BSA for them leading treks. In most years one, two, or more might or might not be offered a different low level less high-profile job at scout camp. Amongst the senior program staff, our personal guideline for student certification was simple: "Would I trust this person to lead my own child safely into the wilderness and have them return smiling, having had a good positive time?". If the answer to that was not easily in the positive, then they fail the program training. It was an easy thing to observe and could in most cases be easily justified by documenting each student's ability to demonstrate a good and safe trustworthy performance.

My wife was hired to become the office manager at one of the resident camps not far from our home for six summers. I would help out when I could and I guided a few of those week-long treks when we were shorthanded of younger trek leaders and too many troops wanted to go on trek that week. We had the best time when a troop wanted to paddle the Lows Lake - Oswegatchie traverse. Lots of paddling, navigation exercises, and a 3-mile portage. I had troops return the following year and they requested me to guide them again on that route. Unfortunately, that BSA camp, among several others, is now closed.

My son and his best buddy both achieved Eagle at the same time and had a common pin on ceremony. My son went on to graduate from the Air Force Academy and his friend went to West Point, and they are still best friends, visiting each other often. My son retired as a Lt Col fighter instructor pilot and he now pilots commercial airliners. His friend is now an army general and still refers to my wife as "Den Mom". I believe the dedication and commitment to complete their "trail to Eagle" was key to their life successes.
 
Last edited:
I have regretted not earning the Eagle.
I sometimes regret not getting Eagle but, then again, when working the High Adventure programs, I was always amazed how many kids wore that badge and had no clue what they were doing.

When I was in, the mantra was "2/3 of scouting is outing" and we lived by that. We had very few Eagles but every one of us could remain comfortably outdoors in any season.
 
I was amazed and shocked over the years at how much many of the merit badges and other requirements were dumbed down from what was once required. During my short time as a young scout, I had to learn and be tested in Morse Code to make it to First Class rank. Nothing llike that any more.
 
Last edited:
When I think back to my days when active in scouting from the late 1950’s through summer 1964, I recall finding many of the merit badge requirements fairly easy to meet, more a matter of showing up and doing the requirements rather than demonstrating mastery. Some such as Lifesaving were fairy demanding and at summer camp had a pass rate of maybe 50%. I viewed most merit badge curriculums to be an introduction to the topic not necessarily making one competent in it. This really came home to me after gaining Sailing merit at camp and then later that summer taking sailing lessons at the local yacht club which involved half day lessons 5 days per week for 2 weeks. At summer camp I was introduced to sailing and at the yacht club I actually gained enough competence to handle small sail boats inshore on Lake Michigan.
 
"Advancement" was not something that was emphasized in our Scout troop. We were too busy having fun and learning things. I never even made First Class. By the time we were around 13 we were in the Christian Service Brigade. Kids started having an interest in girls. We suspected that some of our counselors were gay. It was time to quit and move on. The time was short in the two organizations, but it taught us some independence doing trips away from home.

We started doing our own trips without adults by then. My Dad gave us plenty of encouragement. We were camping on an island for a week and backpacking without adults by the age of 13. Some kids were a little younger. By the age of 16 we were doing over night road trips to the beach.

Kids today have prolonged adolescence. They lack independence. Many don't even get driver's licenses. They hang around with Mom and Dad. It is all foreign to me and hard to understand. Boy Scouts taught me to confident away from home at age 10.
 
I think it's a great program! My dad was in scouting - still have his badges and handbook (2st edition) - Star around 1924. I joined Club Scouts in 1959 I think, stayed till around 1970. Life. Staff on year (Camp Woodlands in Constantia). Both my sons did whole thing Vind through 18 or 19 - both Eagle Scouts in 2008 and 2010. Either one could have moved out on their own around 14 or 15, Scouts playing a part of that. I started canoeing with Scouts when my first son turned 14 and been addicted to it since.
 
I was a Cub Scout and then a Boy Scout in Troop 2, Staten Island, New York. Scouts is where I first went camping, but we did no canoeing. I made Star and was a couple of badges short of Life when I quit. None of my best friends were in the troop and I simply lost interest.

Here's a picture of me in my Cub Scout den in 1955:

Cub Scouts3.jpg
 
I was a Cub Scout and then a Boy Scout in Troop 2, Staten Island, New York. Scouts is where I first went camping, but we did no canoeing. I made Star and was a couple of badges short of Life when I quit. None of my best friends were in the troop and I simply lost interest.

Here's a picture of me in my Cub Scout den in 1955:

View attachment 145365

Are you guys physically holding Arthur still for the photo? A lot of hands on that kid.

Alan
 
Most of the kids I knew that were in the Cub Scouts never made it to Boy Scouts.
One of the most valuable lessons I learned was how to work in a group. Lots of kids at first had little knowledge. We kind of helped them along. Some got homesick, some were physically not very strong, and there was plenty of bad equipment and mistakes. We learned a lot on every trip. We had a couple of volunteer Dads that would show up and they each contributed something different.

I remember one trip in the fall with lots of rain. We did some stupid things like putting tarps under our tents that extended beyond the tent foot print. I woke up in a pool of water. Everyone was cold and wet and discouraged. Kids wanted to go home. The guest Dad put up a big tarp we could stand up under. He built a great warming fire. Then we started making a big pot of mulligan stew with what ever was left at the end of the trip. Within 2 hours we were warm, dry and fed. The morale completely changed. I never forget that guy and what he taught us. We have all faced some bad trips and the suggestion of mutiny and cutting trips short. Get busy and fix it is my motto. Thanks to that "guest Dad" 60 years ago.
 
It's of interest to me to read of your experiences. I was exceptionally fortunate to enter a troop with a long, colorful history. The troop's second scoutmaster was a veteran of trench warfare with the US 316th Infantry in WWI, his influence including an emphasis on military style discipline has continued to this day. In my era in particular, we had a bachelor scoutmaster whose imagination and leadership took many of us to places most kid (or adults for that matter) only dream of. He took me to summits in the Swiss, French, and Japan Alps, as well as the Nepal Himalaya to 5550 meters altitude. Canoeing, both white water and tripping was a big part of that, but we also hiked and climbed in the Adirondack High Peaks, the Presidential Range in NH, etc. in all seasons. Technical rock climbing, advanced first aid training, opportunity to demonstrate leadership among the boys as we advanced helped many of us to become capable, independent, adults.

https://paoli1.org/historians-corner/troop-1-history/ Here's a link to my troop's history for those interested, it's pretty amazing.
 
Back
Top